Open each one as if it were the real site. Spend 30 seconds in each. The one Luna wants to keep scrolling on is the right one. Switch between them by changing the last letter of the URL: /a · /b · /c · /d. The hybrid (/d) is what I'd ship if you let me pick.
A · Editorial · /a
Magazine spread, grown up.
Cream, sage accent, Fraunces serif. Reads as someone who'd be taken seriously by an admissions reader. Quietest of the four.
Most college-app appropriateB · Y2K · /b
Personality forward, sticker energy.
Pastels, hand-drawn accents, soft shadows. Reads as confidently 16. Personality, not portfolio.
Most "this is mine"C · Cosmic · /c
Lean into the .space domain.
Near-black, star field, mint accent. Most distinctive. Slightly riskier — depends on whether Luna wants the astronomy thread to be the dominant note.
Most distinctiveD · Hybrid (recommended) · /d
Editorial bones · Cosmic skin · Y2K warmth.
Serif headlines on a warm-dark background, mint accent, one handwritten flourish for personality. Mature without being austere. Personality without being twee.
My pick